Demographic parameters of the indigenous egg parasitoids, Trichogramma spp., parasitizing the invasive tomato leafminer, Tuta absoluta (Meyrick) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae)

Abstract

Tuta absoluta (Meyrick) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae), one of the most destructive pests of tomato, has recently invaded India. Before recommending any bio-control agent for its control, it is important to study the demographic parameters of the bio-agent on the pest. The present study evaluates the demographic parameters of indigenous trichogrammatids namely Trichogramma achaeae Nagaraja and Nagarkatti, T. pretiosum Riley, T. chilonis (Ishii), and T. pieridis Nagaraja and Prashanth against this pest, aiming to select the most effective egg parasitoid species. Significant differences were observed among the demographic parameters of different Trichogramma spp. Parasitization potential of a thelytokous strain of T. pretiosum was the highest, followed by T. achaeae, T. chilonis, and T. pieridis. Population growth parameters net reproductive rate, intrinsic rate of natural increase, finite rate of increase, and weekly multiplication rate were highest, and generation time and doubling period were shortest for T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae, T. chilonis, and T. pieridis. The study concluded that T. pretiosum could be considered a potential candidate for biological control of T. absoluta; however, field evaluation is required before final recommendation.

Background

Outside its native home, Tuta absoluta (Meyrick) (Lepidoptera: Gelechiidae) was detected for the first time in Spain in 2006 (Urbaneja et al. 2008), and since then, it has invaded many countries including India (CABI 2018). At present, the pest has spread to almost all the tomato growing parts of India (Sridhar et al. 2014; Ballal et al. 2016 and Sharma and Gavkare 2017). The larvae cause damage by mining into the leaves, shoots, flowers, buds, and fruits (Sharma and Gavkare 2017). Previous reports indicate that in newly invaded areas, the pest immediately attained the status of a serious pest of tomato causing 100% crop damage in the absence of control measures (Arturo et al. 2012 and Ballal et al. 2016). The pest is extremely difficult to control with insecticides, and sometimes, as high as 14 rounds of sprays in a growing season were required (Luna et al. 2012). It is, therefore, important to develop sustainable, cost-effective, and eco-friendly alternative management strategies for this pest. Biological control based on the use of trichogrammatids can, therefore, be a viable option (van Lenteren 2012). The possible use of Trichogramma spp. as biological control agents of T. absoluta is currently considered all over the world because of the natural parasitism on the pest by different Trichogramma species (Zappala et al. 2012 and Goda et al. 2015). The effectiveness of a bio-control agent is directly related to its fitness. Survival, fecundity, and development time are the most important parameters that determine the fitness of a natural enemy. The successful use of Trichogramma spp. in biological control depends on knowledge of their biotic potential against the target pest and the thermal requirements (Coelho et al. 2016). Different Trichogramma species and/or strains differ in their efficiency against the target pest, thus, making it necessary to study the performance of different species/strains of Trichogramma on the target pest (Bueno et al. 2009). Implementation of the Nagoya protocol on access to genetic resources and the fair and equitable sharing of benefits under the convention of biological diversity impose restrictions on the importation and release of the effective strains outside their area of origin. Due to these reasons, it is necessary to evaluate first the indigenous species/strains of natural enemies against the invasive pests. In the preliminary evaluation, it is important to study the population growth parameters, especially the intrinsic rate of increase, because not only it does directly represent their biotic potential, but also it determines the releasing strategy (i.e., inoculative, seasonal inoculative, or inundative) (van Lenteren 1986) and compares hosts (Iranipour et al. 2009). Parasitism rate, emergence rate, longevity, developmental time, total fecundity, and sex ratio are the other biological parameters used to evaluate the performance of natural enemies against pests (El-Wakeil 2007).

The present study comprises, therefore, attempts to study the biological and population growth parameters of indigenous trichogrammatids against the invasive tomato leafminer, T. absoluta, in order to select the most effective species and/or strain that can be used successfully to control the pest in tomato cultivations

Materials and methods

Insect cultures

Tuta absoluta

Stock culture of T. absoluta was raised in the laboratory from field collected larvae on tomato leaves in insect rearing cages (45 × 45 × 45 cm) fitted with glass on three sides and nylon net on the front side. Larval food was changed daily or on alternate days depending upon the requirement until larvae reached the pupal stage. Obtained pupae were kept in glass tubes until adults’ emergence. Newly emerged adults were transferred to insect rearing cages to allow mating and were provided by 30% honey solution (in cotton swabs) as food and fresh tomato leaves (petioles immersed in water in plastic tubes) as a substrate for oviposition. Two days after exposure, the leaves having T. absoluta eggs were transferred to another cage and observed until hatching. The neonate larvae were carefully transferred by the aid of a fine camel hairbrush to fresh tomato leaves and reared as described above. T. absoluta was reared and multiplied for two generations to have sufficient culture for experiments.

Trichogramma spp.

Nucleus cultures of the indigenous trichogrammatids T. achaeae, T. pretiosum (thelytokous strain), T. chilonis, and T. pieridis were obtained from the Bio-Control Research Laboratory of the Department of Entomology, Dr. Y S Parmar, University of Horticulture and Forestry, Nauni, Solan (HP), India. Each Trichogramma species was further raised separately on the eggs of T. absoluta in the laboratory. Freshly laid eggs of T. absoluta on tomato leaves, after UV eradiation for 45 min, were exposed to respective Trichogramma species for 24 h in a glass tube for parasitism. After 24 h, the eggs were transferred to another glass tube and observed daily for the emergence of the parasitoid adults. The emerged adults were kept for mating and provided with 30% honey streaked on the side wall of the tube for feeding. Each Trichogramma species was reared for one generation before being used in experiments. The environmental conditions used for raising the cultures and conducting the experiments were 25 ± 0.5 °C, 70 ± 5% RH, and 12 L:12D photoperiod.

Developmental biology

Developmental biology of each species was studied on T. absoluta eggs under laboratory conditions. For this purpose, 12-h-old adults of each species were sexed and every couple was offered 30 T. absoluta eggs on a tomato leaflet in a glass tube in a no-choice experiment. After 24 h, the eggs were transferred to another tube and observed daily for parasitism and emergence of the parasitoid adults. Every set was replicated ten times. After 24 h exposure, the exposed eggs for parasitism were replaced by other new fresh 30 eggs of the host. Exposure and replacement of eggs was repeated until all the parasitoids’ adults died. The parasitized eggs were carefully reared as described earlier. Host eggs, which hatched normally, were the unparasitized, while those which turned black and failed to hatch were considered as parasitized. As the immature stages of the parasitoid species completed their development, the period from starting exposure of the host eggs until parasitoid adult’s emergence was recorded as egg-adult emergence period. Observations on the duration of egg to adult emergence, adult longevity, percent of adults’ emergence, parasitization percent, sex ratio, and fecundity (host parasitism basis) were recorded. The data were subjected to one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) after appropriate transformation through an online software OP-STAT available at http://www.hu.ernet.in. (Sheoran et al. 1998), and significantly different means were separated by least significant difference (LSD) or critical difference (CD) at p = 0.05.

Population growth parameters

Fertility tables were constructed to study the population growth parameters of each Trichogramma species reared on T. absoluta eggs. For this purpose, one pair (10 replicates) of newly emerged adults was offered with 30 host eggs on tomato leaflet in a glass tube. After 24 h, the host eggs were removed and kept for the emergence of the parasitoid’s adults. Obtained adults were sexed under a microscope and every single pair was offered 30 eggs of the host. After 24 h, the old batch of eggs was replaced by a new fresh healthy batch and the process was continued until the last parasitoid adult died. The host eggs were kept separately until the emergence of adults. The host eggs, which turned black and failed to hatch, were considered as parasitized and counted for the fecundity of the parasitoids. Daily survival and fecundity data were used to construct life-fertility tables of each parasitoid on the host separately to calculate the population growth parameters as follows:

• x = Age of the individuals in days (pivotal age), l_x = the proportion of females still alive at age x (survival rate), and m_x = the number of female eggs laid per female at the age x (fecundity rate). Data thus obtained were used to calculate the following population growth parameters or fertility parameters:

• i. The net reproductive rate (R_o): rate of multiplication of the population in each generation, measured in terms of females produced per generation, calculated as R_o = Σl_xm_x (females produced/female)

• ii. Intrinsic rate of natural increase (rm): intrinsic rate of increase (rm) was calculated by using the expression Σ (e^−rmx l_xm_x) = 1

• iii. Mean generation time (T): the mean period elapsing from the birth of parents to the birth of offspring, calculated by the formula T = Log_e R_o/rm

• iv. Finite rate of natural increase (λ): the number of times the population increases per unit time, calculated by the formula: λ = Antilog_e rm.

• v. The weekly multiplication rate: number of times the population increases in a week, calculated by the formula (WE) = e^7rm.

• vi. The doubling time (DT): the time taken in days by a species to double its population, calculated by the formula DT = log_e 2/rm

The jack-knife procedure was used to recalculate the above parameters. The jack-knife method removes one observation from the original data set and recalculates the parameter of interest from the truncated data set. These new estimates, also called as pseudovalues, were further used to calculate the fresh values of each parameter, which serve as replications for the parameter to calculate mean and variances (Maia et al. 2000).

Data analysis

Data on the survival, development, fecundity, and population growth parameters of the pest on different hosts were subjected to one-way analysis of variance through an online software OP-STAT available at http://www.hau.ernet.in. (Sheoran et al. 1998), and significantly different means were separated by least significant difference (LSD) or critical difference (CD) at p = 0.05.

Results and discussion

Developmental biology

Trichogramma spp. under study differed significantly in their efficacy to parasitize T. absoluta eggs. Highest parasitism (84.22%) was resulted by T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae (73.78%), T. chilonis (70.33%), and T. pieridis (62.56%). T. achaeae and T. chilonis showed the same efficacy, but both were superior to T. pieridis and inferior to T. pretiosum in parasitizing the host eggs. The developmental time from the egg until adult emergence varied from 10.5 to 10.8 days, with insignificant difference among species. Percentage of adults’ emergence was also highest (89.16%) in T. pretiosum, being almost on par with T. achaeae (88.83%), while the minimum occurred in T. pieridis (82.75%) (Table 1). Female longevity (4.17 days) was also longer in T. pretiosum than other species (3.5 to 3.53 days). Similarly, the females of T. achaeae and T. pretiosum were more fecund (55.9 and 54.75 eggs/female, respectively) than T. chilonis (51.44 eggs/female) and T. pieridis (41.48 eggs/female). In the four species under study, females lived longer than males and the sex ratio was female-biased varying from 1:1.48 (male to female) in T. peiridis to 0:1 in T. pretiosum.

Table 1 Biological parameters of Trichogramma spp. (second generation) on Tuta absoluta eggs in tomato

Among the four trichogrammatid species, T. pretiosum had the best biological and population growth parameters on T. absoluta than the remaining three species. However, T. achaeae was able to match T. pretiosum with respect to the percentage of adult emergence and fecundity. Host parasitism by different egg parasitoids (62.56–84.22%), obtained in the present study, was close to (65.9–91.74%) that recorded by previous authors who studied the percentages of parasitism by different Trichogramma spp. against different hosts (Chailleux et al. 2012 and Cabello et al. 2012). Adults’ emergence from the parasitized host eggs was more than 80% in each case, which is not so far from the findings of Ballal et al. (2016) who reported 91.01 to 97.5% adult emergence in T. pretiosum parasitizing T. absoluta. Immature developmental period appears not to show much variation (9–10.8 days) with the egg parasitoid or the host insect, when reared at 25 °C (Bueno et al. 2010; Perveen et al. 2012 and Krechemer and Foerster 2015). Female longevity, however, varied with both the parasitoid and the host species. Female’s longevity of T. pretiosum (4.17 days) was longer on T. absoluta (present study) than that recorded on T. ni (2 days) (Bueno et al. 2010). Female longevity of T. chilonis on T. absoluta (3.53 days), recorded in the present study, was shorter than recorded on eggs of S. cerealella (4.3 days) (Perveen et al. 2012), Corcyra cephalonica (3.76–5.6 days) (Perveen et al. 2012 and Vigneswaran et al. 2017), and H. armigera (6.7 days) (Puneeth and Vijayan 2014). The present study confirmed a longer longevity for females than males; this finding agrees with Puneeth and Vijayan (2014) who reported the same phenomenon in T. chilonis on H. armigera. The fecundity of Trichogramma spp. under study varied from 41.48 to 55.9 eggs/female. Eggs reproductively of T. pretiosum (54.75 eggs/female) on T. absoluta recorded in the present study was almost the same (59.82 eggs/female) as that previously recorded by Pratissoli and Parra (2000) for this species on the same host. The fecundity of T. pretiosum on T. absoluta was, however, much higher than that recorded for T. ostrinae on O. nubilalis (22.4 eggs/female) (Hoffmann et al. 1995). The present study assured a female-biased sex ratio in all the tested Trichogramma spp. and confirmed the earlier reports where a female skewed sex ratio was found in T. pretiosum and T. chilonis on different hosts (Bueno et al. 2010 and Krechemer and Foerster 2015).

Population growth parameters

Survival up to adults’ emergence was highest (87%) for T. pieridis, followed by T. pretiosum, T. chilonis (82%), and T. achaeae (73%), which occurred on the 11th day of the pivotal age in each species (Fig. 1). Thereafter, the survival rate decreased gradually and all the parasitoids’ adults died on the 15th, 17th, 16th, and 16th day of the pivotal age in T. achaeae, T. pretiosum, T. chilonis, and T. pieridis, respectively. As for the age-specific fecundity, all the Trichogramma species started ovipositing on the first day after adult’s emergence and continued for the next 5 days (Fig. 2). All the egg parasitoid species achieved their highest daily fecundity on the 12th day of the pivotal age, being 13.86, 17.32, 12.70, and 10.78 female eggs/female for T. achaeae, T. pretiosum, T. chilonis, and T. pieridis, respectively. Population growth parameters, except true generation time, varied significantly among species (GRR: F_{3, 36} = 253.04, p < 0.001; R_o: F_{3, 36} = 905.7, p < 0.001; Tc: F_{3, 36} = 2.91, p = 0.048; rc: F_{3, 36} = 128.85, p < 0.001; rm: F_{3, 36} = 82.49, p < 0.001; T: F_3.36 = 0.88, p = 0.462; λ: F_{3, 36} = 12.24, p < 0.001; DT: F_{3, 36} = 55.93, p < 0.001; WM: F_{3, 36} = 105.71, p < 0.001) (Table 2). Gross reproductive rate (GRR), net reproductive rate (R_o), innate capacity for natural increase (rc), true intrinsic rate of increase (rm), finite rate of natural increase (λ), and weekly multiplication rate (WM) were highest, and doubling time (DT) was lowest for T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae, T. chilonis, and T. pieridis, indicating that T. pretiosum had the ability to grow faster than the rest of species, while foraging against T. absoluta eggs in tomato. The higher population growth of T. pretiosum could be attributed to the fact that the strain of this species used in the study was a thelytokous one, where all individuals contribute towards the population growth. Among the arrhenotokous species, T. achaeae had slightly better population growth parameters than T. chilonis, whereas T. pieridis was the poorest among all. Net reproductive rate (R_o) and intrinsic rate of increase (rm) were maximum (30.61 females/female and 0.3285 females/female/day) for T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae (20.62 females/female and 0.2390 females/female/day), T. chilonis (18.03 females/female and 0.2292 females/female/day), and T. pieridis (14.9 females/female and 0.2228 females/female/day), respectively. Different Trichogramma spp. under study did not vary significantly with respect to their generation time (12.14 to 12.61 days). Like other population growth parameters, the finite rate of increase was highest (1.39 females/day) for T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae (1.29), T. chilonis (1.26), and lastly T. pieridis (1.2). T. pretiosum had the capacity to double its population in (2.06 days) with weekly multiplication rate of (9.46 times). T. achaeae, T. chilonis, and T. pieridis, on the other hand, required 2.89, 3.02, and 3.10 days to double their populations with weekly multiplication rates of 5.29-, 4.96-, and 4.76-folds, respectively.

Fig. 1

Comparison of age-specific survival (lx) of Trichogramma spp. on Tuta absoluta

Fig. 2

Comparison of age-specific fecundity (mx) of Trichogramma spp. on Tuta absoluta

Table 2 Comparison of population growth parameters of Trichogramma spp. parasitizing Tuta absoluta in tomato

Selection of a quality bio-control agent is crucial for any successful bio-control program. Quality of a bio-control agent is generally assessed by its survival rate, fecundity, generation time, sex ratio, multiplication rate, etc. Fertility tables summarize the information on the biological performance of the species taking into consideration the age-specific survival and fecundity of the species to determine the net reproductive rate (R_o) and intrinsic rate of natural increase (rm). The intrinsic rate of natural increase is a measure of the biotic potential of the species. It integrates the effect of the fertility factors into a single value. Hence, this parameter can be used as a single parameter instead of comparing several life history parameters, e.g., development rate, longevity, fecundity, and sex ratio (Havelka and Zemek 1999). The intrinsic rate of increase can be also used to determine the finite rate of increase (λ), which depicts the number of times the population increases per unit time in a generation. Population growth parameters such as intrinsic rate of increase, net reproductive rate, and finite rate of increase are influenced by nature and quality of the host (Qiu et al. 2013).

Data of the present study reports that the net reproductive rate, intrinsic rate of increase, finite rate of increase, and weekly multiplication rate were highest, and generation time and doubling time were the lowest for T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae, T. chilonis, and T. pieridis, indicating the highest population growth for T. pretiosum. The reason for the higher population growth of T. pretiosum could be attributed to the fact that the strain used of this species in the present study was a thelytokous one where all individuals contribute towards the population growth. Among arrhenotokous species, T. achaeae had slightly better population growth parameters than T. chilonis, whereas, T. pieridis was the poorest among all. The gross reproductive rate and net reproductive rate of different egg parasitoid species, reported in the present study, falls within the range reported by (Pratissoli et al. 2004a, b and Iranipour et al. 2009) for different Trichogramma spp. on different host species.

The intrinsic rate of increase, also called as the specific growth rate, was also the maximum (0.3285 females/female/day) for T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae (0.2390 females/female/day), T. chilonis (0.2292 females/female/day), and T. pieridis (0.2228 females/female/day), respectively. The intrinsic rate of increase of T. pretiosum, recorded in the present study, is not so far from those recorded by Pratissoli and Parra (2000) and Pratissoli et al. (2004a) for the same Trichogramma sp. on T. absoluta and S. cerealella eggs (0.31 and 0.299 females/female/day, respectively). The generation time for all the species under study (12.14–12.61 days) agree with the findings of Pratissoli and Parra (2000) and Pratissoli et al. (2004a) (13.32 and 11.74 days) for T. pretiosum on T. absoluta and S. cerealella eggs, respectively. Like other population growth parameters, finite rate of increase was also highest 1.39 (females/day) for T. pretiosum, followed by T. achaeae (1.29), T. chilonis (1.26), and T. pieridis (1.2). Earlier, Pratissoli and Parra (2000) reported that T. pretiosum had a finite rate of increase of 1.349 females/day on T. absoluta eggs, which is very close to that obtained in the present study. T. pretiosum had the capacity to double its population in (2.06 days) with weekly multiplication rate of 9.46 times. T. achaeae, T. chilonis, and T. peiridis, on the other hand, required 2.89, 3.02, and 3.10 days to double their populations with weekly multiplication rates of 5.29-, 4.96-, and 4.76-folds, respectively. All these species required a slightly longer time to double their population than T. cacoeciae on Cadra cautella (1.26 to 1.28 days) (Ozder and Kara 2010).

The present study reports significant variations in the population growth parameters of different Trichogramma species under study. Interspecific variations about the population growth parameters in Trichogramma spp. have also been reported in earlier studies (Pratissoli and Parra 2000; Pratissoli et al. 2004a, b; Ozder and Kara 2010). Population growth parameters also varied with the host and the net reproductive rate (R_o), the intrinsic rate of increase (rm), the finite rate of increase (λ), and the mean generation time (T) of T. pretiosum on S. cerealella eggs at 25 °C was 34.05, 0.299, 1.349, and 11.74, respectively (Pratissoli et al. 2004a). Rearing temperature is another important factor that can significantly affect the population parameters. Fertility life table of T. pretiosum and T. acacioi on A. kuheniella showed an inverse relationship between the generation time (T) and temperature. When temperature increased from 15 to 35 °C, the generation time of T. pretiosum and T. acacioi decreased from 49.76 to 7.54 and 50.66 to 7.55 days, respectively (Pratissoli et al. 2004b). The gross reproductive rate of these species varied from 13.98 to 54.97 and 9.36 to 62.89 with a maximum value achieved at 30 and 20 °C, respectively. The true intrinsic rate and the finite rate of natural increase of T. pretiosum and T. acacioi increased between 15 and 30 °C and 25 and 30 °C, respectively (Pratissoli et al. 2004b). Similarly, the doubling time of Trichogramma cacoeciae on Cadra cautella noted at 25 and 30 °C was 1.28 and 1.26, respectively (Ozder and Kara 2010). Among different physical factors, the temperature was reported to have the strongest influence on the biological characteristics of Trichogramma by Noldus (1989) and Pratissoli (1995). On the basis of the present and previous studies, it could be inferred that different species of Trichogramma vary in population parameters impacted by rearing temperature and the host insect.

Conclusion

Among the evaluated Trichogramma species, the thelytokous strain of T. pretiosum exhibited better biological and population growth parameters against T. absoluta and can be a potential candidate for inundative releases against the pest. However, further studies on field evaluation of the parasitoid against the pest are required before recommending the parasitoid for biological control of the pest.