- Open Access
Effect of temperature and soil moisture on the efficacy of indigenous and imported strains of the entomopathogenic nematode, Heterorhabditis sp. against the black cutworm, Agrotis ipsilon (Hufnagel) (Lepidoptera/Noctuidae)
Egyptian Journal of Biological Pest Control volume 32, Article number: 28 (2022)
Biotic and abiotic factors influence survival, infectivity, development, reproduction, and activity of the entomopathogenic nematodes (EPNs). EPNs have been used to suppress the soil-inhabitant insects, which applied as a successful biological control agent against the black cutworm, Agrotis ipsilon (Hufnagel) (Lepidoptera/Noctuidae) larvae, and pupae.
Studying the effect of different temperatures 20, 25, and 30°C ± 2, and the soil moisture content at 10, 15, and 25% on the susceptibility of two Heterorhabditis sp. strains, Egyptian strain (TAN5) and imported strain (Hb88) against the A. ipsilon 4th and 6th larval instars and 3-day-old pupae was carried out under laboratory conditions. The tested concentrations of the two strains were 30, 60, 120, 240, and 480 IJs/cm2 of soil surface. The mortality rate of 4th instar A. ipsilon larvae was high after Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 treatments at all concentrations, which ranged between (24 and 100%) and (6–100%) at 25°C and 30°C, respectively. At 20°C, Heterorhabditis strain Hb88 recorded higher mortality percentages for A. ipsilon 4th and 6th larval instars and pupae than the indigenous strain TAN5. The soil moisture content of 25% gave the highest mortality rates for the 4th instar larvae of A. ipsilon after treatments of the two strains. The Egyptian Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 was tolerant to the increase in temperature and more tolerant to the change in the water content of the soil than the imported strain Hb88 at all concentrations tested. In a semi-field experiment, Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 at concentrations between (1000–8000 IJs/cm2 of soil surface) showed mortality rates (27–95%) for 4th instar A. ipsilon larvae and (19–81%) for the 3-day-old pupae, respectively.
Heterorhabditis strains TAN5 can was utilized against the black cutworm of A. ipsilon at the temperatures 25 and 30°C. Heterorhabditis strains TAN5 and Hb88 can be utilized against the black cutworm of A. ipsilon at the soil moisture content from 15 to 25%. In the semi-field experiment, Heterorhabditis TAN5 and Hb88 strains were effective against larvae and pupae of A. ipsilon at high concentrations of the nematodes.
The black cutworm, Agrotis ipsilon (Hufnagel) (Lepidoptera/Noctuidae), is an important pest that attacks several economically important crops in Egypt and worldwide (Sharaby and El-Nojiban 2015). A. ipsilon is difficult to combat due to larval hiding behavior during the day the insect remains buried in the ground, which obstructs their vision. Often used the chemical methods of control this pest (Devi 2020). A. ipsilon spends most of its survival in the soil where many microorganisms survive, including entomopathogenic nematodes (EPNs). EPNs are long utilized to control soil-inhabitant insects like cutworms and are effective biological control agents against A. ipsilon larvae (Yuksel and Ramazan 2018). EPNs are one of the most important biological control agents against many agricultural pests soil-inhabiting especially, lepidopteran larvae and pupae, because of their presence below ground (Vashisth et al. 2013). EPNs of Steinernema and Heterorhabditis with their associated symbiotic bacteria Xenorhabdus and Photorhabdus, respectively spread in soils (Grewal et al. 2005). When infected the host pest to nematodes, associated symbiotic bacteria are released from the nematode intestine and multiply rapidly in the host hemolymph, causing septicemia within 24–48 h. The nematodes feed upon the bacterial cells and the tissues of insects and mature, mate, and produce the new progeny of infective juveniles (IJs) emerge from the cadaver begin searching for new hosts (Gaugler 1988). EPNs have the search-ability of hosts and the possibility to survive in the soil. They have free-living infective juveniles (IJs) that can survive a long time without feeding (Koppenhöfer et al. 2000). The utilization of EPNs is prevailing in many countries and regions of the world and could be grown in vast numbers at comparatively low expenses (Mutegi et al. 2018). The survival, infectivity, development, and reproduction of EPNs are adversely affected when presented to unsuitable environmental conditions. Among the different environmental factors, temperature, moisture, and ultraviolet radiation play an important role in their effectiveness (Sharmila et al. 2018). Yuksel and Ramazan (2018) studied the effectiveness of two Heterorhabditis sp. against the fourth instar larvae of A. ipsilon at different concentrations under laboratory conditions. The most elevated mortality rate (100%) was attained within 2 days after inoculation. EPNs are potent and effective against A. ipsilon; therefore, they are used as biocontrol agents, environmentally safe instead of insecticides (Sobhy et al. 2020).
The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of the biotic and abiotic factors (the temperature and the soil moisture content) of an Egyptian and imported strain of the EPN, Heterorhabditis sp. against the black cutworm, A. ipsilon under laboratory and semi-field conditions.
Rearing of Agrotis ipsilon
Agrotis ipsilon larvae used in this study were collected from a vegetable field at Giza Governorate, Egypt, latitude 31.01° north and height above the sea level 30 m. The 4th instar larvae were reared singly inside plastic tubes (1.5 cm in diameter, 15 cm in height) or in small groups in plastic jars to avoid cannibalism until the last instar of the larvae developed to the pupal stage. All pupae were transferred into suitable cages, emerging adult moths were fed by on 20% honey solution till mating and laying eggs. All rearing procedures were carried out at 25 ± 1°C and 75 ± 5% RH (Zhang et al. 2019). The newly hatched larvae were transferred into small plastic jars and provided daily with castor bean leaves (Ricinus communis L.) as a source of food.
Rearing of Galleria mellonella
The greater wax moth, G. mellonella (L.), larvae were collected from injured hives and put in jars (2 kg capacity) until the appearance of moths and reared according to the method illustrated by Birah et al. (2008); the media used are (wheat (130 g), wheat bran (130 g), milk powder (130 g), maize flour (97.5 g), yeast powder (97.5 g), wax (26 g), honey (195 ml) and glycerol (195 ml). Related components with different rates were modified the used media later by Huang et al. (2010).
Entomopathogenic nematode strains
Heterorhabditis strains: Heterorhabditis bacteriophora Pionar (Hb88 strain) was obtained from Randy Gaugler, Rutgers University, New Brunswick NJ, USA, and Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 that isolated by Nouh (2021) was collected from the Noubaria El-Bhaira governorate, Egypt, at Egyptian clover (Trifolium alexandrinum). Mass culturing of both nematode strains occurred in vivo using larvae of G. mellonella as a host (Woodring and Kaya 1988).
Effect of temperature
Infection of the EPNs was carried out to the 4th and 6th larval instars and 3-day-old pupae of A. ipsilon in plastic cups (30 cm3) half-filled with moistened sterile sandy soil (agricultural sandy soil were obtained from Nubarya, Beheira Governorate, Egypt (latitude 31.03° north and height above the sea level 9 m) and used in all the laboratory experiments after being sterilized) and then covered with plastic lids. A 100g of castor bean leaves (R. communis) were offered for daily food. Cups were treated with each strain of Heterorhabditis at 5 concentrations 30, 60, 120, 240, and 480 IJs/cm2 of soil surface. Ten larvae and 3-day-old pupae were used/cup/5 replicates/concentration. The experiments were carried out at three temperatures 20, 25, and 30 ± 2°C and 55–60 ± 2% RH. Water content in the soil was 20% of the soil weight.
Effect of soil moisture content
Infection of the EPNs on 4th and 6th larval instars and 3-day-old pupae of A. ipsilon was the same as the previous described method with some changes in soil moisture and temperature. The experiment was conducted at 25 ± 2°C and 55–60 ± 2% RH, and three different water contents in the soil were 10, 15, and 25% of the soil weight. Cups were treated by the two Heterorhabditis strains (TAN5 and Hb88) at five concentrations of 30, 60, 120, 240, and 480 IJs/cm2 of soil surface. Ten of larvae or 3-day-old pupae were used/ cup/ 5 replicates/ concentration, with 100-g castor bean leaves (R. communis) as a means of daily nutrition.
This experiment was carried out in large plastic boxes filled with 1-kg moistened sterile sandy soil. Nematode strains used each strain placed individually at concentrations of 1000, 2000, 4000, and 8000 IJs/cm2 where the soil surface was applied by (100 ml) water and mixed with the sterile sandy soil and placed inside boxes. In this experiment, 25 individuals of the 4th instar larvae or 3-day-old pupae were placed in a large plastic box (30 × 15 × 15 cm), covered with plastic lids with the castor leaves (R. communis) as a means of daily nutrition. Larvae and pupae were used/ plastic box/ 4 replicates/ concentration. The experiment was carried out at the temperature of 25°C ± 2 open air in November inside the biological control Department and water content in the soil at 20% and 55–60% ± 2 RH.
In all experiments, mortality rates of 4th and 6th larval instars or 3-day-old pupae of A. ipsilon were transferred after 4 days of treatment to White traps to make sure that they were infected with nematodes (White 1927). The third-stage juveniles (IJs) were harvested from the water surrounding White’s trap within 10–14 days of emergence from their hosts. The control remediation was carried out utilizing distilled water.
Mortality rates were corrected according to Abbott’s formula (1925). Mortality rates of A. ipsilon larvae and pupae by Heterorhabditis strains TAN5 and Hb88 were statistically analyzed by ANOVA one way. T test was calculated between the mortality percentage of treated larval and pupal A. ipsilon (Snedecor and Cochran 1980).
Effect of temperature
Data in Table 1) showed mortality percentages of A. ipsilon, 4 days after applying different concentrations of Heterorhabditis strains TAN5 and Hb88 at different temperatures. Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 had higher mortality rate than Heterorhabditis strain Hb88 at 25 and 30°C at the tested concentrations. The percent mortality increased as the concentration of infective juveniles (IJs) increased. The mortality rate of A. ipsilon in 4th instar larvae was high with Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 treatments in all concentrations, where they ranged from 24 to 100% and from 6 to 100% at 25°C and 30°C, respectively. Mortality rate decreased from 6 to 80% at 20°C, while Heterorhabditis strain Hb88 at 20°C had higher mortality percentage of A. ipsilon in 4th and 6th larval instars and pupae than Heterorhabditis strain TAN5. The 4th instar larvae were more susceptible than the 6th ones and pupae at all temperatures. The highest mortality rate by the two strains was recorded at 25°C. Eventually, the biocontrol efficacy of the EPNs against insect pests is impacted greatly by temperature. Table 1 shows the effect of three temperatures on the two Heterorhabditis strains against A. ipsilon 4th and 6th larval instars and pupae. Average mortality of Heterorhabditis strains in larvae and pupae differed non-significantly between the different concentrations at the three tested degrees of temperature 20, 25, and 30°C (F = 0.6114 and 0.3525), (F = 0.0907 and 0.0732) and (F = 0.2007 and 0.1761), respectively.
Effect of moisture
Soil moisture is also an influential factor for nematode movement and survival but increase moisture in the soil may cause death to nematodes due to lack of oxygen. Table 2 shows mortality percentages of A. ipsilon 4 days after applying different concentrations of Heterorhabditis strains TAN5 and Hb88 at different moisture. Heterorhabditis strains TAN5 and Hb88 were affected by a loss of soil moisture when the water content of the soil to 10 and 15%, which led to a decrease in the mortality rates of A. ipsilon at the tested concentrations. The mortality rate by Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 ranged between 8 to 64% and 14 to 90%, at soil moisture 10 and 15%, respectively, while for Heterorhabditis strain Hb88 was between 6 to 58% and 12 to 90%, on the 4th instar A. ipsilon larvae at the same moisture contents, respectively. The soil moisture content of 25% gave the highest mortality rate at the 4th instar larvae of A. ipsilon with the two strains. Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 caused mortality rate from 20 to 100%, while Heterorhabditis strain Hb88 mortality rate was from 18 to 100% at soil moisture 25%, respectively. Table 2 shows the effect of three soil moisture contents on two Heterorhabditis strains against A. ipsilon 4th and 6th larval instars and the pupae. The average mortality of Heterorhabditis strains in larvae and pupae differed non-significantly among the different concentrations at three soil moistures content 10, 15, and 25% (F = 2.0687 and 2.1778), (F = 0.1268 and 0.1888) and (F = 0.1398 and 0.2235), respectively.
In the semi-field experiment, the respective mortality rates of 4th instar larvae and pupae of A. ipsilon were from 27 to 95%, and from 19 to 81%, respectively, when used the Egyptian Heterorhabditis strain TAN5. While when using the highest concentration of the imported Heterorhabditis strain Hb88, mortality rates were 89 and 75% for larvae and pupae, respectively. The mortality rates in the lowest concentration were 21 and 13% in larvae and pupae, respectively. Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 and Hb88 were effective against larvae and pupae of A. ipsilon, especially in the highest concentrations of the two tested nematodes. Table 3 shows the mortality for the two Heterorhabditis strains against the 4th instar larvae and pupae of A. ipsilon. Non-significant differences among the mortality rates at different concentrations of the two strains were recorded between larvae and pupae.
Morton and Garcia-del-pino (2009) and Sharmila et al. (2018) studied the optimum temperature for infection and reproduction of different nematode strains from Heterorhabditis. Infection with Heterorhabditis at temperatures under 15°C was not effective, while at temperatures between 15 to 35°C, its infectivity reached to the optimum and gave high mortality rates. The highest infection and pest mortality rates by Heterorhabditidae sp. were recorded at 20°C. The effects of some Heterorhabditidae species showed at the optimum temperature of 25°C. Hassan et al. (2016) studied H. bacteriophora Poinar (Hb88 strain) against the 4th and 6th larval instars of A. ipsilon at 25°C, which indicated that the 4th instar larvae were the most infected instars than the 6th instar. After 4 days of infection, mortality rates ranged from 35.71 to 78.57% for the 4th instar larvae of A. ipsilon, while ranged from 6.67 to 53.33% for the 6th instar larvae. These results were consistent with the obtained ones where the 4th instar larvae was more sensitive to nematode infection than the 6th instar and contradict with mortality percentages of results in the present study. Also, in agreement with the present findings, Shapiro-Ilan et al. (2009) reported that the optimum temperature was from 25 to 30°C, which recorded high mortality rates. Sharmila et al. (2017) studied the activity of EPNs against A. ipsilon larvae in laboratory conditions. It was found that larvae were highly susceptible to the nematode, Heterorhabditis sp. and the percentage mortality increased with the increase in nematode concentrations. Yuksel and Ramazan (2018) studied the efficacy of local EPN isolates against the 4th instar larvae of A. ipsilon under laboratory conditions at 25 ± 1°C. The mortality rates increased with an increase in the tested concentrations. The highest mortality rate reached (100%) when treated with local Heterorhabditis bacteriophora. The results showed that all local EPN isolates can be used successfully in controlling A. ipsilon larvae. This research was concordant with the results under study, where the mortality rate increased by increasing the concentration. The local strain was more effective than the imported strain, and the mortality rate reached 100% at the highest concentration. Sobhy et al. (2020) evaluated the efficacy of the EPNs, Heterorhabditis bacteriophora against the larval stage of the black cutworm, A. ipsilon under laboratory conditions at 25 ± 2°C. The data indicated that 200 IJs/dish was the most effective concentration against the tested larval instars from the 2nd to 6th instars of A. ipsilon after 72 h because the mortality percentage was 100%, while in the current study, the highest mortality rate of 100% was obtained at the highest concentration of 320 IJs/cup against the 4th and 6th larval instars of the cutworm after 4 days of infection.
Alekseev et al. (2006) studied the effect of soil moisture on the movement and persistence of EPNs. While natural habitats of nematodes are within the soil, many agricultural pests spending their life or part of their life cycle in the soil as well. Therefore, consideration of the effect of the soil moisture on nematode activity is a prerequisite for the successful use of EPNs. Rohde et al. (2010) and Sharmila et al. (2018) observed that soil moisture was also an important factor for nematode mobility and survival, where EPNs require an adequate soil moisture for survival and movement. Heterorhabditis sp. has a low potential of being alive in case of desiccation. Soil moisture levels varying between 10 and 30% had a significant effect on nematode survival. That is consistent with the present study, where the best mortality rates were at 20–25% soil moisture. Chandel et al. (2021) studied the effect of EPNs such as H. bacteriophora to control cutworms, those are hidden in the soil during the day, and the effectiveness of nematodes was related to the soil moisture. It was found that these findings agree the current study where the soil moisture is an important factor for the nematode movement, infection and reproduction.
It was concluded that the Egyptian Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 was tolerant to temperature changes, especially the increase in temperature and more tolerant to the change in water content of the soil than the imported Heterorhabditis strain Hb88. In the semi-field experiment, Heterorhabditis strain TAN5 and Hb88 were effective against larvae and pupae of A. ipsilon, especially in the high concentrations of the two tested nematodes. Eventually, the efficacy of the EPNs against insect pests is impacted greatly by temperature and soil moisture. The two strains can be efficiently used in the biological control of the black cutworm, A. ipsilon, and it can be included in the integrated control programs.
Availability of data and materials
The data that support the findings of this study are openly available.
Trifolium alexandrinum Nubaria
Abbott WS (1925) A method of computing the effectiveness of an insecticide. J Econ Entomol 18:265–267
Alekseev E, Glazer I, Samish M (2006) Effect of soil texture and moisture on the activity of entomopathogenic nematodes against female Boophilus annulatus ticks. Biocontrol 2006(51):507–518
Birah A, Chilana P, Shukla UK, Gupta GP (2008) Mass rearing of greater wax moth Galleria mellonella on artificial diet. Indian J Entomol 70(4):389–392
Chandel RS, Verma KS, Rana A, Sanjta S, Badiyala A, Vashisth S, Kumar R, Baloda AS (2021) The ecology and management of cutworms in India. J Orient Insects. https://doi.org/10.1080/00305316.2021.1936256
Devi G (2020) Management of cutworm by entomopathogenic nematodes—a review. Int J Curr Microbiol Appl Sci 9(6):2520–2526
Gaugler R (1988) Ecological considerations in the biological control of soil–inhabiting insect pests with entomopathogenic nematodes. Agric Ecosyst Environ 24:351–360
Grewal P, Ehlers RU, Shapiroiian DI (eds) (2005) Nematodes as biocontrol agents. CABI Publishing, Wallingford
Hassan HA, Shairra SA, Ibrahim SS (2016) Virulence of entomopathogenic nematodes Steinernema glaseri and Heterorhabditis bacteriophora Poinar (HP88 strain) Against the Black Cutworm, Agrotis ipsilon. Egypt Acad J Biolog Sci 9(1):33–48
Huang CH, Pan XH, Huang DF, Wang BH, Wei GL (2010) Screening of artificial feed formulae for Galleria mellonella L. Gusnhci. Agric Sci 41(7):672–674
Koppenhöfer AM, Ganguly S, Kaya HK (2000) Ecological characterisation of Steinernema monticolum, a cold-adapted entomopathogenic nematode from Korea. Nematology 2(4):407–416
Morton A, Garcia-del-pino F (2009) Ecological characterization of entomopathogenic nematodos isolated in stone fruit orchard soils of Mediterranean areas. J Invertebr Pathol 102:203–213
Mutegi DM, Dora K, John WK, Charles W (2018) Integrated use of Kenyan entomopathogenic nematodes (Steinernema species) and neem against Tuta absoluta on tomato. Int J Res Agric Sci 4:2348–3997
Nouh MG (2021) Efficacy of the entomopathogenic nematode isolates against Spodoptera littoralis (Boisduval) and Agrotis ipsilon (Hufnagel) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Egypt J Biol Pest Control 31:34
Rohde C, Moino JA, Silva MA, Carvalho FD, Ferreira CS (2010) Influence of soil temperature and moisture on the infectivity of entomopathogenic nematodes (Rhabditida: Heterorhabditidae, Steinernematidae) against larvae of Ceratitis capitata (Wiedemann) (Diptera: Tephritidae). Neotrop Entomol 39:608–611
Shapiro-Ilan DI, Mbata GN, Nguyen KB, Peat SM, Blackburn D, Adams B (2009) Characterization of biocontrol traits in the entomopathogenic nematode Heterorhabditis georgiana (Kesha strain) and phylogenetic analysis of the nematode’s symbiotic bacteria. Biol Control 51:377–387
Sharaby A, El-Nojiban A (2015) Evaluation of some plant essential oils against the black cutworms Agrotis ipsilon. Glob J Adv Res 2(4):701–711
Sharmila R, Subramanian S, Rajesh R (2017) Bio control efficacy of entomopathogenic nematodes against black cutworms, Agrotis ipsilon (Hufnagel) (Noctuidae: Lepidoptera) in Potato. Chem Sci Rev Lett 6(21):219–224
Sharmila R, Shanmuga Priya M, Subramanian S, Poornima K, Pandiyan M (2018) Review on ecology of entomopathogenic nematodes. J Entomol Zool Stud 6(4):1086–1093
Snedecor GW, Cochran WG (1980) Statistical methods, 2nd edn. Iowa State University, Ames, p 318
Sobhy HM, Abdel-Bary NA, Harras FA, Faragalla FH, Husseinen HI (2020) Efficacy of entomopathogenic nematodes against Spodoptera littoralis (Boisd.) and Agrotis ipsilon (H.) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Egypt J Biol Pest Control 30:73
Vashisth S, Chandel YS, Sharma PK (2013) Entomopathogenic nematodes a review. Agric Rev 34(3):163–175
White GF (1927) A method for obtaining infective nematode larvae from cultures. Science 66:302–303
Woodring LJ, Kaya KH (1988) Steinernematid and Heterorhabditid nematodes. A Handbook of biology and techniques. Southern Cooperative Series Bulletin. A publication of the nematode subcommittee of the Southern Research Project S135-Entomopathogens for use in Pest Management Systems. Arkansas Agricultural Experimental Station, Fayetteville Arkansas
Yuksel E, Ramazan C (2018) Evaluation of local isolates of entomopathogenic nematodes for the management of black cutworm, Agrotis ipsilon Hufnagel (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae). Egypt J Biol Pest Control 28:82
Zhang Z, Xu C, Ding J, Zhao Y, Lin J, Liu F, Mu W (2019) Cyantraniliprole seed treatment efficiency against Agrotis ipsilon (Lepidoptera: Ctuidae) and residue concentrations in corn plants and soil. Pest Manag Sci 75:464–1472
There is no funding.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
I agree to remain by the ethics of publishing in the journal and do all the experiments and review the research.
Consent for publication
I agree to publish the research in the journal Egyptian Journal of Biological Pest Control.
The author declares that I have no conflict of interest.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Nouh, G.M. Effect of temperature and soil moisture on the efficacy of indigenous and imported strains of the entomopathogenic nematode, Heterorhabditis sp. against the black cutworm, Agrotis ipsilon (Hufnagel) (Lepidoptera/Noctuidae). Egypt J Biol Pest Control 32, 28 (2022). https://doi.org/10.1186/s41938-022-00507-9
- Entomopathogenic nematodes
- Heterorhabditis sp.
- Agrotis ipsilon
- Soil moisture content