Effect of a low cost diet on the cotton leaf worm, Spodoptera littoralis nucleopolyhedrosis virus pathogenicity and sterile insect technique

Abstract

Background

Mass rearing cost of Spodoptera littoralis (Boisd.) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) is one of the critical methods for the successful utilization of Baculovirus pathogenicity and sterile insect technique (SIT). Effectiveness of both SIT and S. littoralis Nucleopolyhedrosis Virus (SpliNPV) was assessed in response to plant-based diet and substitution of agar with commercial sources of gelling components as feed.

Results

Pupal and adult recoveries produced by castor bean leaves were significantly high, followed by the agar-based diet. Moreover, larval durations were significantly prolonged for (starch + gelatin)-based diet than the other dietary diets. Obviously, SpliNPV pathogenicity against the larvae reared on (starch + gelatin)-based diet was 2.5 and 2 times higher than those reared on castor leaves and agar-based diet, respectively. Contrary to expectation, the sterility doses of male moths produced by castor leaves and agar-based diet were relatively similar.

Conclusion

The findings suggest that the lowest cost diets (starch + gelatin)-based diet could be used effectively for increasing the SpliNPV pathogenicity, while either castor leaves or agar-based diet could be considered as a promising choice for SIT program.

Background

The cotton leaf-worm, Spodoptera littoralis (Boisd.) (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) is an economic pest of numerous cultivated plants in many regions. It is considered a serious polyphagous pest in different countries, attacking many vegetable and field crops worldwide (El-Helaly et al. 2020). Use of Baculovirus and Sterile Insect Technique (SIT) could be effective strategies against S. littoralis to substitute chemical pesticides that have diverse impacts on the environment and its fauna (Sayed and El-Helaly 2018). Facilitating S. littoralis in a low-cost diet is one of the key tasks for the successful use of SIT (Calkins and Parker 2021) and also Baculovirus production (Mabrouk et al. 2001). S. littoralis Nucleopolyhedrosis virus (SpliNPV) is belonging to Baculovirus that has a high pathogenic specificity on only S. littoralis making it highly safe environmental control agent (Elmenofy et al. 2020). Pathogenicity of NPV may be improved if any factor goes in line with the insect host immunity that could be influenced by modifying the artificial diets (Chen et al. 2018). Additionally, the susceptibility of lepidopteran larvae to viral infections could be altered by various diets (Shikano et al. 2010). Recently, SIT is widely applied against various pest insects in many regions (Dyck et al. 2021). It depends on releasing the sterile adults of targeted insect previously irradiated with gamma or X-ray into the field. Sterile moths should be facilitated in high numbers with a good quality to suppress the population effectively (Hendrichs et al. 2002). The associate cost, time, space and ingredients availability of insect food are the tools for improving the insect rearing facilities (Assemila et al. 2012). Many artificial diets have been known to rear S. littoralis species; however, developing these artificial diets are continuously required to optimize the reared insect for SpliNPV production and SIT program. Larval diet was recently applied, depends on agar ingredient as gelling agent, is a very expensive and imported product in the most countries. Alternative ingredients or decreasing their significant amount by commercial and cheap alternative gelling sources will be useful. Therefore, this trial aimed to evaluate gelatin and starch ingredients as alternative gelling sources for rearing S. littoralis, and it does indeed have a multivariate optimization perspective, taking into account of Baculovirus production and SIT performance, as well as dietary cost.

Methods

Test insect

A colony of S littoralis was maintained under laboratory conditions at 25 ± 2 °C and 65% ± 10 R.H. Full-formed pupae were supplied in the adult rearing cage (40 × 20 × 10 cm) with small cups containing pieces of cotton wool soaked with 10% sugar for feeding the emergent moths. Egg-masses were collected daily and transferred to glass gars (1600 cc), covered with muslin cloth, until they hatch. The newly hatched larvae were transferred to rounded plastic bowls (70 × 15 cm) with castor bean leaves, Ricinus communis for feeding and covered with both muslin cloths until pupating.

Larval feed substrate

Two gelling agents, starch and gelatin powders (local market), were used to replace Agar Agar powder (landor, Co Ltd, USA), used for semi-artificial diets described by Shorey and Hale (1965). Five semi-artificial diets were tested: agar-based diet (A), starch-based diet (S), gelatin-based diet (G), starch + gelatin based diet (SG) and agar + starch + gelatin-based diet (ASG) were tested alongside the castor leaves-based diet (CL) (Table 1). One hundered nwely hatched larvae, with 5 replicates, were used. Reared larvae were weighted during their development at the age of 5, 9 and 13 days, using a laboratory balance. Five replicates, with 10 larvae each treatment, were weighted. Resultant pupae from each treatment were collected daily, sexed and stored in waxed paper cups on moist sawdust and covered with muslin cloth. Five replicates of newly formed pupae (10 pupae each) were collected at the same day of formation and weighted at the 5 days old.

Table 1 Ingredients of 6 tested diets based on gelling agent rearing Spodoptera littoralis larvae as compared to the castor plant diet and their cost study

Bioassay of insect diet and SpliNPV production

Local isolate of SpliNPV was used in the bioassay experiments. The pathogenicity was evaluated on the 2nd instar larvae of S. littoralis. Eight different virus concentrations from 1 × 10² to 1 × 10⁹ BIPs/ml. (polyhedral inclusion bodies (PIB)/ml) were prepared from the stock concentration that was 2.3 × 10⁹ PIB/ml. The interaction of NPV pathogenicity and dietary larvae was referred as a mortality-response andwas calculated, accoeding to the bioassy standard method previously described (Sun et al. 2004), namely 1 ml of each concentation was spread on the surface special plate (20 × 10 × 3 cm) divided to 50 cells containing 50 ml of the tested semi artificial diets. Distilled water was used for untreated control experiments. Then, 50 larvae were allowed to feed onto the died until death or pupation. Each treatment was repeated in 5 replicates. Mortality responses in each treatment of larvae, fed on different artificial diets, were daily recorded.

Irradiation technique

Full grown male pupae of S. littoralis before emergence (24 h) were irradiated by the sub sterlizing doses 150, 200 and 250 Gy (Gy), using Cobalt 60 gamma cell located at the Nuclear Research Cener, at a dose rate of 0.60 Gy/min. Effect of gamma irradiation on male sterility was evaluated based on egg hatch. Newly emerged male moths resulted from irradiated pupae were paired with un-irradiated females. Each pair was introduced into 75 cc cylindrical glass cage internally lined with papers as an ovipositional site and covered with muslin cloth. Cages were supplied by 10% sugar solution as feed. The experiment was conducted with 15 replicates per treatment. Daily deposited eggs of irradiated and un-irradiated treatments were collected (fecundity), counted, and kept 5 days for calculating the parentage of hatched eggs (fertility). Sterility index was calculated according to the Toppozada et al. (1966) formula: % sterility = [1 − (Fu × FeI/Fc × Fec)] × 100, where: Fu = fecundity of un-irradiated treatment; FeI = fertility of irradiated treatment; Fc = fecundity of control; and Fec = fertility of control.

Statistical analysis

Biological and biochemical studies were examined by one way analysis of variance (ANOVA) technique, means were analyzed by Tukey’s multiple range test, when the (p < 0.01), the ANOVA statistics are significant. Mortality response of S. littoralis larvae of several diets were analyzed, using Probit analysis, slope. LC₅₀ was calculated according to Finney (1971). The reproduction rate averages were calculated by the model designed by Regniere et al. (2012), the trendline labels were created by Excel 2010.

Results

The cost impact of modified diets was presented in Table 1 the Gel cost/kg diet for each diet which were lower (0.0, 0.15 and 0.42 US $) for CL, S and SG diets, respectively than (0.75, 1.41 and 2.4 US $) for G, ASG and A diets, respectively. Moreover, substituting full and partial amount of agar by gelatin and starch reduced the diet cost by 82.5% and 41.25, respectively per one kilogram of diets (Table 1).

Pupae and adults production were significantly different from the tested larval diets (p < 0.001) as shown in Fig. 1. No pupae was produced by starch-based diet (S) and gelatin-based diet (G), while the percentage of pupal recovery of (starch + gelatin)-based diet (SG) was lower (39.4%) than those were recorded (61.8, 85.2 and 89.2%) (F_(3,16) = 170.8, p < 0.001) of by (agar + starch + gelatin)-based diet (ASG), agar-based diet (A) and castor leaves-based diet (CL), respectively. The same trend was noticed in the adult recovery whereas the highest percentage of adult moths was produced by A diet (78.8%) followed by CL diet (75.21%), ASG diet (45.4) and SG diet (20.6), (F_(3,16) = 148.29, p < 0.001).

Fig. 1

Percentages of pupal and adult recovery produced by 6 different larval diets of Spodoptera littoralis

The data in Table 2 showed that the weight of larvae fed on diet CL was significantly heavier than those fed on artificial diets, while the lowest larval weight was recorded in the ASG and SG diets at the periods of 7 days (F_(3,16) = 109.1), 10 days (F_(3,16) = 130.1) and 13 days (F_(3,16) = 158.4) with p < 0.001. In the same table, the pupal weight for castor CL diet and agar-based A diet were significantly heavier than those fed on ASG diet and SG diet (F_(3,16) = 139.5, p < 0.001).

Table 2 Weight averages of three ages (day) of larvae and 24 age pupae produced from 4 different larval diets of Spodoptera littoralis

Data in Fig. 2, showed the duration of larvae fed on A, ASG and SG diets was significantly prolonged than those fed on CL diet (F_(3,16) = 121.4, p < 0.001). However the duration of pupae resulted from larvae fed on CL and A were significantly lower than those fed on ASG and SG diets (F_(3,16) = 24.8, p < 0.001).

Fig. 2

Averages of larval and pupal durations in response to using 4 different diets for rearing Spodoptera littoralis larvae

Impact of different diets, as insect feed on SpliNPV pathogenicity, is presented in Fig. 3. The date indicated that a high pathogenicity (LC₅₀ = 3.8 × 10³ PIB/ml) was recorded of the larvae fed on SG diet, followed by those fed on ASG diet (LC₅₀ = 3.9 × 10⁴ PIB/ml), A diet (LC50 = 1.4 × 10⁶ PIB/ml) and CL diet (LC₅₀ = 1.3 × 10⁷ PIB/ml). Data revealed that the mortality of larvae fed on the diet contains starch and gelatin was greater (2 and 2.5 times) as compared to those fed on agar-based diet and castor plant in response to SpliNPV infection. The results revealed that gelling agents may be has important role for insect immunity or susceptibility against SpliNPV infection in particular the low concentrations from 1 × 10² to 10⁵ PIB/ml, the pathogenicity of virus was greatly varied by the different of larval diets, which has been expressed as larval mortality (Fig. 5), and also the changes of larval color (Fig. 4), namely the infection was high in the larvae fed on SG diet (Fig. 4d) followed by ASG diet (Fig. 4c), while the larvae fed on A diet (Fig. 4b) and CL diets (Fig. 4a) exhibited low virus infection.

Fig. 3

(%) mortality of Spodoptera littoralis 2nd instar larvae treated with different concentrations of SpliMNPV (PIB/ml) in response to using 4 different larval diets as feed

Fig. 4:

4th and 5th instar larvae of Spodoptera littoralis treated with low concentration (1 × 10² PIB/ml) SpliMNPV as 2nd instar in response to using 4 different larval diets as feed, CL (b), A (a), ASG (c) and SG (d)

The sterility of the irradiated male moth induced by gamma irradiation which resulted from CL and A is analyzed (Fig. 5). The ASG and SG were ruled out because they were of too low quality to use in SIT program as observed in the previous experiments. Full sterility (100%) were showed for irradiated males with the dose rate 250 Gy of both CL and A diets, however, irradiated males fed on CL diet exhibited less sterility (55.2 and 73.4%) than that resulted from A diet (60.5 and 78.1%) when exposed to the sub-sterilizing doses 100, 150 Gy, respectively. Moreover, the sterility was relatively similar (90.2 and 91.1%) of those fed on CL and A diets, respectively in the case of 200 Gy.

Fig. 5

Percentages of sterility of male adults previously irradiated as pupae with different doses of gamma radiation in response to castor plant (CL) and semi-artificial diets based-agar (A) as larval feed

Discussion

The artificial diets of rearing various lepidopteran insect pest have been promoted successfully, but the most of them have been excluded for using in SIT due to their high cost Marec and Vreysen (2019). Accordingly, replacement of agar with less expensive ingredient such as starch and/or gelatin from the larval diet lead to reduce the mass rearing cost which has been considered one of the key success factors for the implementation of the SITprogram. In the present study, substituting full and partial amount of agar by both gelatin and starch reduced the diet cost by five and twofolds, respectively per one kilogram of diets. Notwithstanding, the evidence that ether gelatin or starch did not succeed in rearing S. littoralis larvae when used individually as substitute of agar, starch was used to as gelling agent by Abbasi et al. (2007) on Helicoverpa armigera and by Amer (2015) on Earias insulana. Furthemore, gelatin was used sucsessfuly by Pascacio-Villafán et al. (2020) for Anastrepha ludens rearing. Result revealed that the dietary of castor plant and the agar-based diet generated heavier larvae and pupae than those containing (starch + gelatin). Furthermore, the larvae fed on castor plants result in shorter duration for pupae than those fed on the artificial diets. These results of larval survival differentials may be attributed to two factors, improved health due to a protective effect or worsened health due to physiological changes (Jiang et al. 2010). It is likely that the castor plant diet and the agar-based diet were of a higher yield than the other tested diets; these current results coincide with the previous studies of the demographic response in Lepidopteran insect to imbalanced nutrients of dietary larvae (Carey 2001). In contrast to the present findings, insignificant differences were found for both survival and production of S. littorals using two diets containing either starch or agar ingredients (Sorour et al. 2011).

Insect biochemical composition and enzymatic activity may be affected as a result of supplying or lacking a small amount of nutrients and the P: C ratio intake by dietary insect. Additionally, the changes of diet physicochemical such as buffering capacity, pH, and redox potential may influence on insects gut conditions and/or made of the food is nutritionally suboptimal required (Johnson and Felton 1996). The most striking feature of these data is that the light weight and extended duration of larvae after dietary feeding could be attributed to the impact of the tested gelling agent agar, starch and gelatin that might cause deleterious insect physiology and different biochemical levels. These gelling agents consist of different protein and carbohydrate ratios that could change the intake of P: C and have a wide range of micronutrients, such as potassium, sodium, calcium and ferric, many of which have physiological processes (Reinecke 2013). These results are consistent with those of Lee et al. (2003), Thompson and Redak (2005) and Nash and Chapman (2014) who concluded that the abandonment of P: C regulations had a negative impact on the development of insects in response to unbalance of macronutrients in the S. littoralis, Manduca sexta (Linnaeus 1763) and Ceratitis capitata (Wiedemann) diets, respectively. In contrast, growth and survival were mostly unchanged by protein and carbohydrate balance in insect diets (Silva et al. 2017).

Results of SpliNPV pathogenicity indicated that the virus actions were varying by the different dietary larvae, whereas it was greatly produced by the larvae reared on (starch + gelatin)-based diet, whilst the larvae reared on castor plant had the lowest susceptible level. These varying of viral pathogenicity may go into the interaction between larval dietary nutrients and insect immunity. The current findings go in line with those of Povey et al. (2104) who found that a low P: C ratio in the larval diet of Spodoptera exempta increased the viral pathogenicity. The potential resistance mechanism of insect to Baculovirus, in response to larval diet was initially reported by Lee et al. (2003) who found that the susceptibility to viral infection and relatively impaired immune function of low dietary P: C ratio was greater than that of high dietary P: C ratio. The loss of the potency of the SpliNPV in the different diets was associated with the theory of the direct effects of insect feed intake on viral pathogenicity and insect growth rate (Chen et al. 2018). Another possible hypothesis is that the dietary compositions may induce inhibition of apoptosis in infected cells, which prevents inflammatory reactions and extinguishes the reactive oxygen species (ROS) that have caused differences in insect viral pathogenicity (Hay et al. 2020). It is known that insect immune system depends on rapid apoptosis of infected Baculovirus cells generating ROS to avoid the viral premature cell multiplication (Circu and Aw 2010). The present results concerning larval susceptibility against SpliNPV due to different diets as feed is consistent with Hoover et al. (2000) who concluded that high ROS levels were generated in the midgut lumen of Heliothis virescens (Fabricius) larvae reared on cotton leaf as compared to those reared on artificial diet.

Even though the (starch + gelatin)- based diets is cheaper than that contains agar-based diet, these diets did not produce sufficient numbers of moth to be considered as candidate diets for S. littoralis mass rearing in SIT program. The different sterility profiles of the irradiated males resulted from the two larval diets, castor plant and agar-based diet are given in the line of evidence supporting the hypothesis that nutritional factor rendering insect to be tolerant or sensitive for irradiation treatments. This trend, evident in the current study, was particularly striking in dietary-sterilizing interaction studies. Unlike females and males have little or no response to radiation-dietary interaction (Carey et al. 2001) but, sterility trajectory of male adults was influenced by nutrients encountered during the developmental stages (Astuti et al. 2020).

Conclusions

The successful use of SIT for S. littoralis management could be achieved by developing the economic value of insect mass rearing. Moreover, high SpliNPV infectivity might be induced by adjusting the larval diet. Commercial and cheap ingredients, gelatin and starch in substitution for agar have been assessed as gelling agent for S. littoralis dietary larvae. Although, the larvae exhibited developmental plasticity and were capable of successfully using the novel gelling ingredients, the deleterious effect of certain biological properties was observed. The results indicated that the quality and quantity of S. littoralis were inhibited with the use of gelatin and starch as gelling agent as compared to agar ingredients. The results suggested that the starch and gelatin–based diet has provided insight into successful SpliNPV production, while the effective diets, castor plant and agar–based diet could be considered as remarkably useful for SIT program.