- Open Access
Competition between two biocontrol agents attacking the thrips, Gynaikothips ficorum (Marchal) (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae), infesting the Cuban laurel, Ficus nitida Thunb., in Egypt
Egyptian Journal of Biological Pest Controlvolume 29, Article number: 36 (2019)
The insect fauna is present in the curled Cuban laurel leaf (Ficus nitida Thunb.) infested with the Cuban laurel thrips, Gynaikothrips ficorum Marchal (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae), in Giza, Egypt, which included pests, predators, and parasitoids. The present study dealt with the presence of two natural enemies of G. ficorum, i.e., the anthocorid predatory bug, Montandoniella moraguesi Puton (Hemiptera: Anthocoridae), and the eulophid parasitoid, Pediobius thysanopterus Marchal. (Hymenoptera: Eulophidae). Inspection of infested leaves revealed the presence of the thrips and the two natural enemies all year round. Numbers of the thrips showed 2 peaks (9500 and 12,000 individuals/100 infested leaves) in 2016 recorded in March and November, respectively. The associated predatory bug, M. moraguesi, occurred in two peaks in March and August by 8000 and 8500 individuals/100 infested leaves, respectively. Meanwhile, the eulophid parasitoid, P. thysanopterus, appeared in low population densities and by only one peak in October 2016 and in August 2017. The same trend for populations of the three concerned insect species was found in 2017. Generally, the very low population of the parasitoid resulted from a severe competition through the dominant voracious predator M. moraguesi that feeds not only on the thrips but also on the larvae and pupae of P. thysanopterus inside their host (G. ficorum) nymphs and prepupae.
Indian laurel trees, Ficus nitida Thunb., are widely spread as ornamental and shadow trees in gardens and streets around the world transferred by international trade of ornamental trees (Mound et al. 1995). In the campus area of the Faculty of Agriculture, Cairo University and Damanhur University, Egypt, ficus trees are always found infested by the invasive thrips Gynaikothrips ficorum (Marchal) (Phlaeothripidae: Thysanoptera). Morcos (1944) recorded this species for the first time in Egypt, as G. (Phoeothrips) ficorum. When infested, young leaves become curled upwards and folded around the midrib forming a sandwich-like bag functioning as a microhabitat harboring all thrip stages occurring together with their associated natural enemies. Two hemipterans and a chrysopid were reported by Morcos (1944) predating on the thrips’ pupae, mentioning that they were too scarce to be of any importance. Other authors in different countries recorded different natural enemies attacking the different stages of G. ficorum on F. nitida, e.g., the predatory anthocorid bugs Orius albidipennis, O. insidiosus, and O. tristicolor recorded by Lewis (1973), Tawfik and Ata (1973), and Jacot-Guillarmod and Brothers (1986). Tawfik (1968) studied the biology of Termatophylum insigne (Termatophylidae) as a predator on adults and nymphs of G. ficorum. Burks (1971) and EL-Husseini et al. (2006) recorded the eulophid parasitoid Pediobius (Pleurotropis) thysanopterus Burks on the nymph and pupae of G. ficorum. Besides, they recorded the parasitic mite Adactylidium sp. (Acarina: Pyemotidae) that was previously recorded by Abreu-Rodriguez (1982) and Antonatos et al. (2011) attacking the eggs of G .ficorum. Awadallah et al. (1975) recorded Chrysoperla carnea Steph. feeding on the nymphs and adults of this thrip species. Meanwhile, Montandoniella moraguesi Puton (Hemiptera: Phlaeothripidae) was recorded by Tawfik and Nagui (1965) and Ibrahim et al. (2013) predating on G. ficorum in Egypt.
As different predatory and parasitoid species were recorded associated with the Cuban laurel thrips, G. ficorum within the infested folded leaves of F. nitida, the present study aimed to shed the light on the relationships between this thrip species and its associated main predator, M. morguesi and the parasitoid, P. thysanopterus, their abundances and their competition in such microhabitat.
Material and methods
At the campus of the Faculty of Agriculture, Cairo University, Giza, Egypt, a weekly sampling of 25 curled/folded leaves was randomly collected from 5 trees (5 leaves/tree) of F. nitida from different directions and heights of the trees. The numbers were grouped monthly (/100 leaves) throughout the sampling period from January to December 2016 and 2017 (EL-Husseini et al. 2006). Sampled leaves were transferred to the laboratory in paper bags for inspection under a stereoscope. Numbers of each species were recorded for two seasons: 2016 and 2017. Rate of predation was calculated for the 2 years 2016 and 2017. The stereomicroscope was provided with regulated illumination that did help in locating the parasitoid larvae inside the mobile thrip larvae.
Numbers of nymphs and adults of the predatory bug M. moraguesi and larvae, pupae, and adults of the parasitoid P. thysanopterus, separately or together inside the same curled F. nitida leaf, were identified by the first author and recorded. In case of both bioagents are found in the same leaf or not, each sampled leaf was kept in a Petri dish, furnished with a moistened filter paper to determine the species individuals coming out (thrips, predator, and/or parasitoid) under the laboratory conditions of 25 ± 1.5 °C and 55 ± 5% RH. A digital camera accessed to a computer was used to shoot photos whenever needed.
Results and discussion
As shown in Table 1, the Cuban laurel thrips, G. ficorum, as well as the anthocorid predatory bug, M. moraguesi, and the parasitoid, P. thysanopterus, were found all year round, associated with different developmental stages inside the microhabitat formed by the infested young leaves. When G. ficorum infests young F. nitida leaves and sucks the sap from the upper leaf surface, the growing leaf rolls itself upwards around the middle rip, forming a flat room with a specific microhabitat inside. Thus, the fauna associated with the thrips also favors such sheltered condition. Populations of the thrips showed 2 peaks in 2016 (9500 and 12,000 individuals/100 infested leaves) recorded in March and September, respectively. By increasing the temperature (30–40 °C) in summer, the number of thrips decreased until August and then increased rapidly in September to record the third peak.
The anthocorid predatory bug, M. moraguesi (nymphs and adults), presented all year in fluctuated numbers related to the numbers of its prey (G. ficorum) that was affected by the prevailing temperature in the area being favored by the high summer temperature. Thus, its numbers overwhelmed those of the thrips in the summer from April to August, showing 2 peaks per year (8000 and 8500 individuals/100 leaves) in March and August (Table 1).
Meanwhile, the eulophid parasitoid, P. thysanopterus, was also found all year round, but with very low numbers in relation to its host (G. ficorum), as presented in Table 1. Taking its alive stages (larvae, pupae, and adults) into consideration, it had only 1 peak (1700 alive individuals/100 infested leaves) in October. Low numbers of the alive parasitoid P. thysanopterus in relation to the killed parasitoid individuals by M. moraguesi in its nymphal stage inside the larvae of its host (G. ficorum) (Fig. 1) could be explained by the high predation rate by the voracious anthocorid predator M. moraguesi (nymphs and adults) (Tawfik and Nagui 1965) (Table 2). The predation rate ranged between 47 and 67% all year around, suppressing the population of the parasitoid. This was a severe competition between this predator and the parasitoid. The predator not only feeds voraciously on the Cuban laurel thrips, which is the host of the parasitoid (Tawfik and Nagui 1965), but also feeds on the developing parasitoid stages (larvae and pupae) developed inside the nymphs of the thrips. These results are in line with those of EL-Husseini et al. (2006).
Population abundance of G. ficorum in the year 2017 is presented in Table 3. It followed the same trend of the year 2016. Thrip numbers showed 2 peaks through the whole year (9000 and 11,000 individuals/infested leaf) recorded in March and November, respectively.
The associated predator, M. moraguesi, also occurred around the year. Its numbers showed 2 peaks (7100 and 6900 individuals, nymphs, and adults) in March and August, respectively. Generally, its numbers were lower than in the year 2016. This could be due to the extremely high temperature in the summer of 2017 that reached 40–45 °C during the months from April to August.
The eulophid parasitoid P. thysanopterus presented also all year round, but in relatively very low numbers (larvae, pupae, and adults) as seen in Table 3. It had only 1 peak (2000 alive individuals/100 infested leaves) in August. This low population of the parasitoid was strongly related to the dominance of the anthocorid predator, M. moraguesi, which competes with the parasitoid by preying on the thrips, the host of the parasitoid, and also the prey of the larvae and pupae of the parasitoid inside the host thrips’ bodies.
As shown in Table 4, the predation rate on the parasitoid, in 2017, was higher than in 2016. It ranged between 59.3 in January and 80.7% in July. This could explain the lower population of the parasitoid in 2017 than in 2016. Such results have not been mentioned previously in the literature.
The two natural enemies of the Cuban laurel thrips, Gynaikothrips ficorum, i.e., the anthocorid predatory bug Montandoniella moraguesi Puton and the eulophid parasitoid Pediobius thysanopterus Marchal, were found all year round inside the curled infested Ficus nitida leaves. The eulophid parasitoid was recorded in very low population densities, resulting from a severe competition through the dominant voracious predator M. moraguesi that feeds not only on the thrips, but also on the larvae and pupae of P. thysanopterus inside their host (G. ficorum) nymphs and prepupae.
Abreu-Rodriguez E (1982) Adactylidium sp. (Acarina: Pyemotidae), a new record of a predatory mite of thrips eggs in Puerto Rico. J Agric Univ P R 66(4):310
Antonatos SA, Kapaxidi EV, Papadoulis GT (2011) Adactylidium gynaikothripsi n. sp. (Acari: Acarophenacidae) associated with Gynaikothrips ficorum (marshal) (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae) from Greece. Int J Acarol 37(Suppl. 1):18–26 https://www.tandfonline.com/toc/taca20/37/sup1?nav=tocList
Awadallah KT, Abou-Zeid NA, Tawfik MFS (1975) Development and fecundity of Chrysopa carnea Stephens. Bull Soc Entomol d'Egypte 59:323–329
Burks BD (1971) A new Pediobius parasitic on a thrips (Hymenoptera: Eulophidae). Proceedings of the Ent Soc Washington 73(2):177–180
EL-Husseini MM, Shahira SHM, Ola OE, Mesbah AH (2006) On the biology and incidence of the parasitoid, Pediobius (Pleurotropis) thysanopterus Burks (Hymenoptera: Eulophidae) parasitizing the Cuban Laurel thrips, Gynaikothrips ficorum (marshal) (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae) in Egypt. Egypt J Biol Pest Control 16(2):107–110
Ibrahim MMA, Tawfik MFS, El Husseini MM (2013) Seasonal abundance of Montandoniella moraguesi Puton (Hemiptera: Phleothripidae) on Ficus nitida Thunb. at Giza, Egypt. Egypt J Biol Pest Conrol 23(1):187–188
Jacot-Guillarmod CF, Brothers DJ (1986) Catalogue of the Thysanoptera of the world, part 7. Ann. Cape Prov. Mus. Nat Hist 17(1):1–93
Lewis T (1973) Thrips - their biology, ecology and economic importance. Department of Entomology, Rothamsted Experimental Station Harpenden, Hertfordshire, England. London, UK. Academic Press, New York
Morcos S (1944) Gynaikothrips ficorum Marchal in Egypt (Thysanoptera). Bull Soc Fouad 1er d'entomol 28:183–187
Mound LA, Chin-Ling; Okajima S, Wang CL (1995) Observations in Taiwan on the identity of the Cuban laurel thrips (Thysanoptera: Phlaeothripidae) in landscape grown Ficus. J Econ Entomol 84(6):1790–1795
Tawfik MFS (1968) The life-history of Termatophylum insigne Reuter (Hemiptera: Termatophylidae). Bull Soc Entomol d'Egypte 52:235–250
Tawfik MFS, Ata AM (1973) The life-history of Orius albidipennis (Reut.) (Hemiptera-Heteroptera: Anthocoridae). Bull Soc Entomol d'Egypte 57:117–126
Tawfik MFS, Nagui A (1965) The biology of Montandoniella motaguesi Puton, a predator of Gainykothips ficorum Marchal in Egypt (Hemiptera: Heteroptera). Bull Soc ent Egypte, XLIX:1–20
The authors thank and highly appreciate the cooperation of Cairo University campus authorities for allowing them to sample the materials from the Ficus trees.
This work was not supported by any funding body, but personally financed.
Availability of data and materials
All data are available in the article, and the materials used in this work are of high transparency and grade and are available to the publisher for use in any form.
The authors declare that they have no competing interest.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
We agree to all the concerned regulations.
Consent for publication
We agree to publish this scientific paper at the EJBPC.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.