Efficacy of biopesticides against the whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae), on parthenocarpic cucumber grown under protected environment in India

The whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Genn.) (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae), is one of the most damaging pests of crops grown in open field and under protected conditions. Owing to the indiscriminate use of insecticides, whitefly has developed resistance against various insecticides belonging to different chemical groups. Use of microbial biopesticides (entomopathogenic fungi) can be an effective alternate to chemical insecticides. This study was planned for the evaluation of entomopathogenic fungi (EPF) formulations, namely, Beauveria bassiana Balsamo (Vuillemin), Lecanicillium lecanii (Zimmerman) Viegas and Metarhizium anisopliae (Metschnikoff) Sorokin and botanical pesticide, Neem Baan, for the management of different life stages of B. tabaci on parthenocarpic cucumber grown under protected conditions. The liquid formulations of Neem Baan at 10 and 15 ml/l were the most effective (90.7 to 93.3% in eggs, 93.3 to 97.1% in nymphs, and 92.4 to 94.2% reduction in whitefly adults after 3rd spray, respectively) as compared to EPF. Among the EPF, L. lecanii and B. bassiana at 10 and 15 ml/l (80.6 to 86.5% in eggs, 85.7 to 91.5% in nymphs, and 58.5 to 69.2% in whitefly adults after 3rd spray, respectively) were found to be more effective than M. anisopliae at 10 and 15 ml/l (78.4 to 82.8% in eggs, 82.5 to 85.9% in nymphs, and 57.7 to 62.8% in whitefly adults after third spray, respectively) in reducing different life stages of B. tabaci on cucumber. Significantly high yield of cucumber fruits was obtained from the plot where Neem Baan at 10 and 15 ml/l (2337.5 to 2420.8 g/plant) was used. Minimum fruit yield were recorded in untreated control plots. The integration of these biopesticides in the management schedule of the whitefly under protected conditions will enhance the quality and market value of parthenocarpic cucumbers.


Background
The whitefly, Bemisia tabaci (Gennadius) (Hemiptera: Aleyrodidae), is a devastating pest of vegetables, ornamentals, and agricultural crops throughout the tropical and subtropical regions of the world (Oliveira et al. 2001). More than 900 plant species are known to be its hosts (GISD 2005). The suitable hosts that support the B. tabaci population include cotton, cabbage, tomato, eggplant, okra, cucumber, squash, melon, and many ornamentals (Li et al. 2011).
Cucumber, Cucumis sativus L., is an important cucurbitaceous vegetable cultivated under different environmental conditions, open fields, and greenhouses for local consumption and exportation. Polynet houses/net houses provide suitable microclimatic conditions for the growth and development of sucking pests. Warm humid conditions are preferred by the sap-sucking insects. The highest population levels force the farmers to use excessive usage of chemicals.
Parthenocarpic cucumbers are one of the important commercial crops grown under protected environment and are the money spinners for the farming community (Sood et al. 2018).
The whitefly, B. tabaci, is one of the most important pests infesting cucumber plants during its three growth stages, seedling, flowering, and fruiting. This pest inflicts damage in two ways: (a) it affects the plant vitality and vigor by sucking significant amount of phloem sap and (b) by interfering in the normal photosynthesis due to growth of sooty mold fungus on the honeydew excreted. This significantly affected the quality and marketability of the harvested products (Oliveira et al. 2001). Whitefly also acts as vectors of several economically important viral plant pathogens causing huge yield losses (van Regenmortel et al. 2000).
Favorable microclimate, availability of tender plant parts for a long period, and more number of generations under poly-house conditions make whitefly management more difficult. Also, all the life stages of whitefly colonize the abaxial surface of leaves, which makes it difficult to achieve effective coverage by insecticidal spraying, leading to frequent applications. Adverse effects like pesticide residues on crop produce (Van Lenteren 2000), killing of non-target organisms (Pilkington et al. 2010), and development of resistance to pesticides (Pappas et al. 2013) are associated with frequent and excessive use of insecticides. It sometimes resulted in the resurgence of the pests making their control more difficult, expensive, and environmentally devastating. Hence, emphasis is being part on insecticide-free control strategies or management of vegetable pests. A long-term irreversible effects of indiscriminate insecticides' usage have necessitated the increased usage reliance on biological control methods (Torrado-Leon et al. 2006).
Owing to the increasing threats of whitefly infestation on cucumber crop and the need for residue-free organic crop, this study was carried out to evaluate the efficacy of EPF formulations on different developmental stages of the whitefly, B. tabaci, on parthenocarpic cucumber grown under protected conditions.

Methods
A field experiment was conducted to evaluate the efficacy of different biopesticides against the whitefly, B. tabaci on parthenocarpic cucumber grown under net house (size, 15 × 7 m = 105 m 2 ). The experiment was conducted in a double-door fated naturally ventilated poly-house structure made of galvanized iron pipes covered with ultraviolet stabilized 40 mesh size net and an arc shaped dome. The trial was laid out at the experimental farm of Department of Vegetable Science during August to December 2017 and 2018 for raising autumn season crops. Thirty-day-old seedlings F 1 hybrid Punjab Kheera-1: Plant is vigorous, bearing 1-2 fruits per node. It is suitable for poly-net house only. Seedlings were transplanted during the last week of August in 2017 and 2018 seasons, keeping row to row and plant to plant distance of 60 cm × 30 cm, respectively. Seedlings were transplanted on 30-cm raised beds. The crop was raised in insecticide free environment by following recommended cultural and management practices for the production of cucumber under naturally ventilated polyhouse (Anonymous 2018). Cucumber plants were trained on single shoots with the help of bamboos and nylon ropes. The extra shoots were pruned regularly to optimize the growth of plants.

Collection and rearing of insects
A stock culture of B. tabaci was maintained on young potted plants of cucumber under screen-house conditions to ensure availability of large number of whiteflies required for artificial infestation of cucumber plants. For this purpose, whitefly adults were initially collected from whitefly infested cucumber plants grown in poly-houses and the identity of species was ascertained prior to raising the cultures. The identified B. tabaci adults were released in large numbers on potted plants of cucumber with the help of aspirator. Older and heavily infested plants were periodically replaced by fresh potted ones. It was practiced regularly throughout the study period.

Testing of biopesticides
Efficacy of different biopesticides including EPF and Neem formulations along with Malathion was evaluated for the management of B. tabaci on parthenocarpic cucumber grown under naturally ventilated polyhouse (Table 1).

Experiment protocol
The experiment was laid out in a randomized block design (RBD) with each concentration of biopesticide as one treatment and 3 replications/ treatment were kept. Apart from these biopesticide treatments (2 dosages), one chemical, Malathion 50 EC (one dosage), and untreated check (no spray) was also maintained for comparison.
There were 10 plants per plot in each biopesticide treatment, separated by distance of 50 cm between 2 plots to avoid chemical interference owing to drift to adjacent treatments. Large numbers of whitefly adults were released in the poly-house 35 days after transplanting (DAT) for early build-up of infestations. For foliar applications of the different biopesticides, a battery-operated knapsack sprayer fitted with hollow cone nozzle (40 PSI pressure) was used. The biopesticides were applied late in the afternoon hours.

Data collection
The observations were recorded on population build-up of whitefly in different biopesticide treatments. There were 3 foliar sprays for all treatments. The first was applied after 55 and 60 days of transplanting (in 2017 and 2018) and repeated at 11 days interval, respectively. Pretreatment and post-treatment observations were recorded on randomly selected 5 plants per plot. The pre-treatment observations (during 2017: 3.6 to 5.7 eggs/ leaf, 14.3 to 19.3 nymphs/leaf, and 5.9 to 7.1 adults/3 leaves; during 2018: 3.3 to 5.4 eggs/leaf, 14.9 to 18.0 nymphs/leaf, and 5.8 to 7.4 adults/3 leaves) were recorded 24 h before spray. The post treatment observations on whitefly eggs and nymphs were recorded from single leaf of the middle canopy of the plant. Adult populations were recorded from 3 leaves each on top, middle, and bottom canopy of the plant. The populations were recorded from randomly selected 5 plants per plot at 10 days' interval after each spray.
The leaves with eggs and nymphs of whitefly were collected and brought to the laboratory. Their numbers were recorded per leaf under a stereo zoom binocular microscope. The observations recorded were analyzed statistically to workout relative efficacy of different biopesticide treatments. Percent reduction in the population of whiteflies (eggs, nymphs, and adults) over control was calculated, using Henderson and Tilton's formula (Henderson and Tilton's 1955).
Corrected Mortality% ¼ 1 − n in Co before treatmentÃn in T after treatment n in Co after treatmentÃn in T before treatment Ã100 where n = whitefly population; T = treated; Co = control.

Marketable fruit yield
Fruits reaching marketable size (about 15 cm in length) were harvested at 5 days interval. Fresh fruit weight per plant at each picking in different treatments was recorded. The fruit weight obtained at each picking was summed up to obtain cumulative fruit yield per plant during the crop season.

Recording of environmental parameters
Environmental parameters viz. minimum and maximum temperature and relative humidity were recorded daily with the help of digital thermo-hygro meter placed inside the polyhouse at canopy height throughout the study period.

Statistical analysis
The mean population of the whitefly eggs, nymphs, and adults (x ± SE PROC) were subjected to analysis of variance (ANOVA), and mean values were compared by Duncan Multiple Range Test (DMRT) (P = 0.05), using SPSS program, version 23 (SPSS 2015), and treatment means were separated at P = 0.05. The analysis of variance was done for the each year separately. Pooled analysis was also done by pooling of treatment PROC values across the sprays for the respective years for all developmental stages of whitefly.

Efficacy of biopesticides against eggs of B. tabaci
In 2017, a day before 1st spray, the eggs population of whiteflies ranged from 3.6 to 5.7 eggs per leaf showing non-significant difference among the evaluated treatments. After 1st spray, all the biopesticides significantly reduced egg population than in the untreated control. Among the 5 treatments, Malathion at 4.0 ml/l (76.8%) exhibited the highest efficacy against the eggs of the whitefly. Among the biopesticides, Neem Baan (at 15 and 10 ml/l (63.7 and 59.8%)) was efficacious, followed by the EPF; L. lecanii (at 15 and 10 ml/l (46.2 and 41.2%)), B. bassiana (at 15 and 10 ml/l (45.5 and 41.8%)), and M. anisopliae (at 15 and 10 ml/l (39.5 and 36.5% PROC)), respectively (Table 2)  After the 3rd spray, Malathion at 4.0 ml/l and Neem Baan at 15 ml/l were statistically at par with each other (97.5 and 93.3% PROC), followed by Neem Baan at 10 ml/l (90.7% reduction). The lowest percent reduction in eggs was recorded in the case of M. anisopliae at 10 ml/l (78.4% reduction) (Temp Max = 22.3°C; Temp Min = 12.9°C ; RH M = 89%; RH E = 60%).
After the 3rd spray, the maximum percent reduction in egg population of whitefly was recorded in Malathion at 4.0 ml/l (98.1%) and it was significantly better than the rest of the treatments. The lowest percent reduction was recorded in case of M. anisopliae at 10 ml/l (81.3%) and it was statistically at par   Table 3).
The pooled analysis of all the biopesticidal treatments after 3 sprays revealed that there was non-significant difference among the treatments in overall reduction (Table 2). Same trend was observed during autumn cropping season of 2018 (Table 3).

Efficacy of biopesticides against nymphs of B. tabaci
In 2017, the number of nymphs of B. tabaci per leaf was counted before the 1st spray and the mean nymph incidence, 1 day before 1st spray, indicated non-significant differences among all the treatments and the mean nymphs populations ranged from 14.3 to 19.3 nymphs per leaf. In the observations recorded after 1st spray, among the different treatments, Malathion at 4.0 ml/l recorded the highest population reduction of nymphs of B. tabaci (75.6%). It was significantly superior to other biopesticidal treatments. The 2nd best treatment was Neem Baan at 15 and 10 ml/l (65.5 and 60.5% PROC). However, the treatments with the EPF; L. lecanii (at 15 and 10 ml/l (51.6 and 49.7%)), B. bassiana (at 15 and 10 ml/l (50.2 and 48.6%)), and M. anisopliae (at 15 and 10 ml/l (48.6 and 46.1%)) were found statistically at par with each other (Table 4)  were the most effective in population reduction of whitefly nymphs whereas B. bassiana (at 10 ml/l (89.0%)) and M. anisopliae (at 15 ml/l (85.0%)) were moderate, while M. anisopliae (at 10 ml/l (82.5% PROC)) was found comparatively less effective in reducing the population of whitefly nymphs after the 3rd spray (Temp Max = 22.3°C; Temp Min = 12.9°C; RH M = 89%; RH E = 60%).
In 2018, the mean population of nymph whiteflies 1 day before of 1st spray ranged between 14.9 and 18.0 nymphs per leaf and showed non-significant uniform distribution of nymphal population in all treatment plots of the field experiment. After 1st spray, Malathion at 4.0 ml/l was the most effective in reducing the nymphs of whiteflies (77.7% reduction). However, it was statistically at par with Neem Baan at 15 and 10 ml/l (62.5 and 57.8% reduction), L. lecanii at 15 ml/l (50.6% reduction), and B. bassiana 15 ml/l (48.2% reduction), respectively. The lowest percent reduction was recorded in the treatment of M. anisopliae at 10 ml/l (41.6% reduction) and it was also statistically at par with M. anisopliae at 15 ml/l (46.1% reduction), L. lecanii at 10 ml/l (46.0% reduction), and B. bassiana at 10 ml/l (46.0% reduction), respectively ( After 3rd spray, Malathion at 4.0 ml/l was found most effective in terms of percent reduction of nymphs of whitefly (99.5% reduction), followed by Neem Baan (at 15 and 10 ml/l (97.1 and 94.5%)), L. lecanii (at 15 ml/l (91.1%)), and B. bassiana (at 15 ml/l (89.9%), respectively, while M. anisopliae at 10 ml/l was found least effective one (83.8% reduction). It was statistically at par with M. anisopliae at 15 ml/l (85.9% reduction), B. bassiana at 10 ml/l (85.8% reduction), and L. lecanii at 10 ml/ l (85.7% reduction), respectively (Temp Max = 27.2°C; Temp Min = 10.8°C; RH M = 88%; RH E = 31%) ( Table 5). The pooled analysis of the 3 sprays for overall reduction of B. tabaci nymphs revealed that among all the treatments, Malathion at 4.0 ml/l gave maximum reduction in nymphs of B. tabaci (88.6%) and it was statistically at par to all other biopesticidal treatments (Table   4). Similar trend was observed during autumn cropping season of 2018 (Table 5).

Efficacy of biopesticides against adults of B. tabaci
In 2017, the variation in the pre-treatment population on adults of B. tabaci in different treatments was statistically non-significant, indicating that the population was uniformly distributed in the net house before the different treatments were imposed. The mean population of  B. tabaci, 1 day before imposing the treatments, was from 5.9 to 7.1 adults per 3 leaves. All the treatments were significantly superior to the untreated control in adults of B. tabaci after 1st, 2nd, and 3rd spray. The highest population reduction over control after the 2nd spray was recorded in Malathion at 4.0 ml/l (88.7%). However, it was statistically at par with Neem Baan at 15 and 10 ml/l (87.0 and 83.9% reduction). The 2nd best treatment was by L. lecanii (at 15 and 10 ml/l (54.5 and 50.5%). It was also statistically at par with other biopesticidal treatments viz., B. bassiana (at 15 and 10 ml/l (50.7 and 47.8% PROC) and M. anisopliae (at 15 and 10 ml/l (45.7 and 46.3% PROC), respectively (Temp Max = 28.0°C; Temp Min = 15.3°C; RH M = 91%; RH E = 53%). Same trend was observed after the 3rd spray and in overall reduction of different biopesticidal treatments, respectively (Table 6).
In 2018, the pre-treatment population of adult whiteflies was uniform in all the experimental treatment plots, since the average population of adults was statistically non-significant. The average pre-treatment population ranged between 5.8 and 7.4 adults per 3 leaves justifying that there was a need to protect the crop from whiteflies infestation.
The data recorded after the 1st spray revealed that population reduction of adults ranged from 36.3 to 77.1% in different treatments. All the biopesticidal treatments were found significantly superior over control in reducing the population of adults. Malathion at 4.0 ml/l (77.1% reduction) was found superior than the other treatments in reducing the population of adults. Neem Baan at 15 and 10 ml/l (61.9 and 59.1% PROC) was found the next best treatment as compared to the rest of the treatments (Temp Max = 26.2°C; Temp Min = 14.2°C; RH M = 90%; RH E = 35%).
After 2nd spray, highest population reduction of adults was observed in the plots treated with Malathion at 4.0 ml/l (91.0% reduction) and found most effective in reducing the population of adults, followed by Neem Baan at 15 and 10 ml/l (85.2 and 82.6% reduction), which was statistically at par with each other. However, the treatments L. lecanii (at 15 and 10 ml/l (56.7 and 53.4% PROC)), B. bassiana (at 15 and 10 ml/l (51.7 and 51.6% PROC)), and M. anisopliae (at 15 and 10 ml/l (49.2 and 47.9% PROC)) were found statistically at par amongst each other though significantly poorer than Neem Baan and Malathion (Temp Max = 27.1°C; Temp Min = 11.0°C; RH M = 90%; RH E = 33%). After 3rd spray also, similar trend was observed ( Table 7).
The pooled data for overall reduction in population of adult whitefly also showed that the treatment Malathion at 4.0 ml/l gave maximum reduction in adults of B. tabaci (89.0% reduction). However, it was statistically at par with Neem Baan at 15 and 10 ml/l (80.4 and 78.0% reduction). M. anisopliae at 10 ml/l gave the lowest reduction (48.2%) and it was also statistically at par with the rest of the treatments (Table 7).

Marketable fruit yield
The cumulative marketable yield of cucumber in different treatments given for the management of B. tabaci infestation under net house condition (Table 8)   cropping season, Malathion at 4.0 ml/l resulted in the highest yield (2468.8 g per plant), followed by Neem Baan (at 15 and 10 ml/l (2381.3 and 2337.5 g per plant)) and L. lecanii (at 15 ml/l (2210.4 g per plant)), being statistically at par to each other. The minimum marketable yield was recorded in case of M. anisopliae (at 15 and 10 ml/l (2131.3 and 2120.8 g per plant)), which was also statistically at par to B. bassiana (at 15 and 10 ml/l (2176.7 and 2137.5 g per plant)) and L. lecanii (at 10 ml/l (2150.0 g per plant)), respectively. The control treatment resulted in a fruit yield of 1802.1 g per plant, which was significantly lower than all the other treatments. Whereas, in 2018, also in Malathion (at 4.0 ml/l) and Neem Baan (at 15 and 10 ml/l) resulted to the maximum fruit yields of 2541.7, 2420.8, and 2375.0 g per plant and these yields were significantly superior to the rest of the treatments, respectively. The yields recorded in all other treatments varied from 2268.8 to 2164.6 g per plant which were statistically at par amongst the treatments. Minimum yield of 1827.1 g per plant was recorded in  the control plot (Table 8) and it was significantly lower than all the other biopesticidal treatments. The effectiveness of neem-based biopesticides has been demonstrated worldwide in both open field and protected conditions. In open field conditions, it is being widely practiced that neem-based biopesticides are applied for management during early season when the infestation/population load is less. Neem as NSKE, Neem oil, and Crude extracts have been used by many workers. Greenhouse whitefly, T. vaporariorum, nymphs and adults can be successfully managed on cucumber, sweet pepper, and tomato by Neem Azal -T/S (Azadirachtin A1 %) under greenhouse protected conditions (Sood et al. 2006;Prijović et al. 2012 andKashyap 2013). Azadirachtin 1% (at 4 and 5 ml/l) results in 68.5-71.0% reduction in population of whitefly on capsicum under net house condition (Singh and Joshi 2020). Neem oil (1-3%) and NSKE (3, 5, and 7%) reduced considerably the population of cotton whitefly (Jat and Jeyakumar 2006). It has also been reported by many workers that the neem-based botanicals are more efficacious against egg and nymphal stages of whitefly as compared to adults.