Skip to main content

Table 1 Efficacy of mineral oils and botanicals on the incidence of Megalurothrips distalis in summer mung bean in 2018

From: Field evaluation of horticultural mineral oils and botanicals against bean thrips, Megalurothrips distalis (Karny) (Thysanoptera: Thripidae), in summer mung bean

Treatment No. of thrips per 10 flowers
Pre treatment 1DAT 3DAT 7DAT 10DAT
MAK All Season HMO 0.3% 10.00 4.00c (2.22) 5.00cd (2.44) 7.33de (2.89) 10.33a (3.36)
Arbofine HMO 0.3% 7.00 2.33abc (1.80) 4.67cd (2.38) 5.00abc (2.44) 9.00a (3.16)
NSKE 5% 5.67 0.67a (1.27) 2.00a (1.72) 4.67ab (2.38) 7.67a (2.94)
Neem Baan 1500 ppm 10 ml l−1 9.00 3.00bc (1.96) 4.33cd (2.31) 6.33bcde (2.71) 9.00a (3.15)
Indo-Neem 1500 ppm 10 ml l−1 8.00 1.33ab (1.52) 4.67cd (2.38) 6.00abcd (2.63) 8.67a (3.11)
Nimbecidine 300 ppm 10 ml l−1 9.00 2.00abc (1.72) 4.33cd (2.29) 6.67cde (2.76) 9.00a (3.14)
Neem Kavach 1500 ppm 10 ml l−1 9.00 2.33abc (1.80) 4.00bc (2.23) 7.00de (2.82) 8.67a (3.09)
Pongamia soap 10 g l−1 6.00 3.33 (2.07c) 5.67 (2.57d) 8.00 (3.00ef) 10.67 (3.40ab)
Rogor 30% EC (dimethoate 30% EC) 250 ml ha−1 8.00 1.33ab (1.47) 2.67ab (1.90) 4.33a (2.31) 8.67a (3.10)
Water 6.67 3.33c (2.07) 8.67e (3.10) 10.00f (3.31) 14.00bc (3.87)
Untreated control 9.00 10.00d (3.31) 12.33 f (3.65) 14.67g (3.95) 17.33c (4.27)
CD (P = 0.05) NS (0.53) (0.34) (0.34) (0.50)
F value; df = 10 1.77 9.23 21.73 16.93 5.46
  1. Means followed by the same letter in each column with treatments did not differ significantly at the 5% level by LSD test. Figures in parentheses are √n + 1 transformed values
  2. DAT days after treatment