Skip to main content

Table 1 Response of various insecticides to Lab-PK, Field, UNSEL and Aceta-SEL populations of Chrysoperla carnea

From: Correction to: Genetics, cross-resistance and realized heritability of resistance to acetamiprid in generalist predator, Chrysoperla carnea (Steph.) (Neuroptera: Chrysopidae)

Strain

Insecticide

LC50 (95% FL) (μg mL-1)

Fit of probit line

Na

RRb

RRc

   

Slope (±SE)

χ2

df

P

   

Lab-PK (G130)

Acetamiprid

0.72 (0.45-0.95)

2.26 (0.36)

1.48

3

0.86

350

1

 

Spinosad

1.15 (0.94-1.32)

3.21 (0.40)

0.46

3

0.98

350

1

 

Buprofezin

4.27 (3.34-5.10)

2.68 (0.35)

1.88

3

0.51

350

1

 

Pyriproxyfen

5.54 (4.53-6.50)

2.55 (0.30)

4.13

3

0.63

350

1

 

Field (G1)

Acetamiprid

1676.07 (1171.58-2867.68)

1.32 (0.26)

1.46

3

0.69

350

2327.87

 

Spinosad

877.29 (607.27-1547.13)

1.31 (0.27)

0.71

3

0.87

350

762.86

 

Buprofezin

113.39 (82.96-160.79)

1.48 (0.26)

5.74

3

0.12

350

26.55

 

Pyriproxyfen

335.77 (274.89- 418.66)

1.68 (0.22)

1.06

3

0.79

350

60.61

 

UNSEL (G16)

Acetamiprid

133.10 (111.35-158.30)

2.00 (0.23)

1.72

3

0.63

350

184.86

 

Spinosad

75.40 (57.90-91.26)

2.24 (0.28)

1.52

3

0.68

350

65.56

 

Buprofezin

16.42 (13.68-18.97)

2.94 (0.34)

2.45

3

0.48

350

3.84

 

Pyriproxyfen

162.53 (138.76-186.15)

2.89 (0.30)

3.80

3

0.28

350

29.33

 

Aceta-SEL (G16)

Acetamiprid

22370.54 (12089.78-99622.35)

1.25 (0.28)

0.30

3

0.82

350

31070.19

13.34

Spinosad

1531.44 (953.33-4323.61)

1.12 (0.23)

1.26

3

0.99

350

1331.69

1.75

Buprofezin

342.52 (221.09-829.50)

1.38 (0.26)

0.92

3

0.74

350

80.21

3.02

Pyriproxyfen

1322.92 (857.01-3174.71)

1.35 (0.27)

1.62

3

0.65

350

238.79

3.94

  1. aN is number of total larvae exposed in bioassay including control
  2. bRR resistance ratio, LC50of Field or UNSEL or Aceta-SEL / LC50 of Lab-PK strain
  3. cRR resistance ratio, LC50 of Aceta-SEL / LC50 of Field strain